| Saigon,
1952, a beautiful, exotic, and mysterious city caught in the
grips of the Vietnamese war of liberation from the French colonial
powers. New arrival Alden Pyle (Brendan Fraser), an idealistic
American aid worker, befriends London Times correspondent Thomas
Fowler (Michael Caine). When Fowler introduces Pyle to his beautiful
young Vietnamese mistress Phuong (Hai Yen) the three become swept
up in a tempestuous love triangle that leads to a series of startling
revelations and finally - murder. Nothing, and no one, is as
it seems, in this adaptation of Graham Greene's classic and prophetic
story of love, betrayal, murder and the origin of the American
war in Southeast Asia. [TRAILER]
STEVEN
SNYDER'S REVIEW
Strip
away its frills, and “The
Quiet American” is about two, stubborn men who enjoy the notion
that they are important.
Both live in Vietnam in the early 1950’s, always aware of the
war between the French and Vietnamese looming in the distance. Alden
Pyle (Brendan Fraser) is a young American doctor, in Vietnam to help
soldiers with an eye disorder. Thomas Fowler (Michael Caine) is an
aging British journalist, covering the war for a London newspaper.
Their lives lead them to interesting places. Pyle works closely with
the American embassy and with a rising third power in the region – a
new leader who promises to beat back both the French and the communists.
Fowler finds himself venturing into North Vietnam, covering scenes
of carnage and bloodshed, and snooping around docks that have been
importing ton after ton of a strange plastic.
Their unquenchable desire for importance does not stop with their
professions. As in all great thrillers, there is a woman, Phuong
(Do Thi Hai Yen).
She is a young dance girl, decades younger than Fowler, but she lives
with him and loves him because he provides for her. He is married
to a woman back in London, but Phuong tells him all the things he
truly wants to hear. With her, he can believe is youthful and attractive
again. He is important and special. And with him, she feels save
from the poverty that has struck so many Vietnamese women.
That is, until Pyle arrives. As they meet, dance and talk, Pyle falls
in love with Phuong, and thus a vicious romantic triangle is formed
that will ultimately turn bloody.
I have not given anything away, I assure you. Within five minutes
of the opening credits, it has been established that Pyle is dead,
assassinated in the dark. The fun of “The Quiet American” is
found in working backwards through flashback; in watching how the
obvious struggle over Phuong slowly turns Fowler and Pyle against
one another.
Others have incorrectly emphasized the importance of the film’s
politics. While war in Vietnam and the politics of America’s
entry into the conflict are always working behind the scenes, the
real drama of this film is found with its unique and complex characters.
Fowler and Pyle’s professions provide the scenarios with which
we become engrossed in their interactions. For instance, Fowler’s
journey to North Korea gives both men their first opportunity to
talk openly about Phuong’s love. Later, Fowler’s attempt
to interview the leader of the rising opposition leaves Fowler and
Pyle stranded together one night in enemy territory.
It is in these moments where they interact in ways a conventional
story could never facilitate. As the war swirls around them, they
confide in each other, even embrace one another, but continue to
view the other as competition for Phuong’s persuadable affections.
I must admit that this film flooded my mind with characters so rich
and believable that I started to think of them as real human beings.
Phuong is the delicate woman, willing to be used because she has
no other options. Pyle is the rigid, but polite man whose only fault
appears to be an excessive level of idealism. And Fowler is a man
who is clinging to one last chance for happiness, and knows it. To
lose Phuong, he says at one point, “would be the beginning
of death.”
There are two twists, which I will not divulge, that spin “The
Quiet American” on its head. In the first, events cause Fowler
to have an emotional breakdown. He has lost control of himself, and
is truly a man on the brink. In the other twist, the war that has
forever passed unnoticed in the background suddenly thrusts itself
into the story, and offers Fowler the tempting proposition of reclaiming
all he’s ever wanted.
And this is where the film’s opening sequence, revealing Pyle’s
death early on, becomes important. In a normal film, Pyle’s
fate would be uncertain, and as Fowler is pushed to the extreme,
we would wonder what is going to happen. But in “The Quiet
American,” we already know who lives and who dies.
This creates an unusual emotional vortex, where we are not focused
intently on what is coming in the future, but on what is occurring
in the present. Temptation, anger and rage suddenly become our paramount
concern, wondering not how the story will end, but what decisions
and actions will take these characters to their predestined fate.
A film so much about characters lives and dies by its acting. Fraser,
as Pyle, finds the balance between polite and irritating, always
seeming to be in the perfect place at the perfect time. Caine gives
the best performance of his career, embodying the melancholy of a
man who senses his time has past, but clings to what he has with
everything he’s got.
During the opening credits, Fowler speaks of Vietnam, and how it
will provide almost anything in exchange for a man’s soul. “The
Quiet American’s” shockingly cynical conclusion – a
dark epilogue in which Fowler’s every temptation and desire
has been fulfilled – proves him right.
Who would have imagined that such a quiet film could speak so loudly.
  
Check out Reviews, Commentary, and More at Zertinet.com |

MOVIE
WEB PAGE
LINKS
TO REVIEWS
The New York Times
Slant Magazine
IMDB
WEB PAGE
MOVIE
REVIEW QUERY ENGINE
Showtimes |